Solid and engineered hardwood are both real wood floors, and both look beautiful once installed. But they’re built differently, and that affects how wide they come, how much you can customize them, how fast you can get them, and where they can go.
Many homeowners walk into our showroom assuming engineered hardwood is just a cheaper version of solid. It isn’t. Each has real differences, and each is the better pick in certain situations.
Here’s how solid vs. engineered hardwood compares, so you can choose the right floor for your home.
What Is Solid Hardwood Flooring?
Solid hardwood is exactly what it sounds like: each board is a single piece of solid wood from top to bottom, usually 3/4″ thick. It comes in many species, including oak, maple, hickory, and birch.
Solid hardwood typically comes in widths from 2¼” to 5″. Its biggest advantage is customization. You choose the:
- Stain: 40+ options to get exactly the colour you want
- Gloss level: from matte to high gloss
- Width: 4¼” is the most popular in 2026, and 3¼” is still common
- Grade: which changes how much natural character shows
- Extras: modifications like wire brushing
Solid hardwood has a slightly narrower, more traditional look. Because the whole board is wood, it can be sanded and refinished many times over its life.
The trade-off is time. Solid hardwood is made to order, so it usually takes 4 to 8 weeks to arrive once you’ve made your selections.
What Is Engineered Hardwood Flooring?
Engineered hardwood is made in layers. A top layer of real hardwood, called the veneer or wear layer, is bonded to a core underneath. Most engineered floors use a plywood core, while some use an HDF (high-density fibreboard) core.
That thin layer of real wood is what you see and walk on, so engineered floors look just like solid hardwood once installed. The layers underneath make the board more stable and let it go places solid wood can’t, like basements and concrete slabs.
Engineered hardwood comes in many thicknesses, widths, stains, and gloss levels. But each product is sold as shown on the sample, so there are no custom stains or modifications.
What you’ll usually find on the shelf:
- Wide planks: most are around 7″ or wider
- Oak: by far the most common species
- Texture: most are wire brushed or lightly textured
- Finish: usually matte
Engineered hardwood is typically in stock at a distributor, so most products arrive within 1 to 3 weeks.
Solid vs. Engineered Hardwood at a Glance
| Solid hardwood | Engineered hardwood | |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | Single piece of wood, 3/4″ thick | Real wood veneer bonded to a plywood or HDF core |
| Typical width | 2¼” to 5″ | 7″ or wider |
| Customization | Choose stain, gloss, width, and grade | Sold as per the sample |
| Lead time | 4 to 8 weeks (made to order) | 1 to 3 weeks |
| Refinishing | Yes, many times | Only with a 3 mm or thicker veneer |
| Installation | Usually nailed down | Usually glue-assist (glue and nail) |
| Basements and concrete | Not usually recommended | Yes |
Installation and Subfloors
Wider boards need more holding power. That’s why most engineered hardwood is installed with glue and nails, while solid is usually just nailed into a wood subfloor. A 5″ solid also needs glue assist, as per NWFA installation guidelines.
Engineered floors also offer more installation options. They can be floated, nailed, or glued, including directly over concrete. That flexibility can mean easier installation in spaces where solid wood isn’t an option.
If you have in-floor radiant heat, many engineered products are approved for it. Always check the product spec before you buy.
Can Engineered Hardwood Be Refinished?
It depends on the veneer, not the brand. Veneers range from 1 to 4 mm thick, and a refinisher needs at least 3 mm to sand the surface safely.
If refinishing down the road matters to you, choose an engineered product with a 3 or 4 mm wear layer. A thin veneer can’t be sanded, so it will need to be replaced once it’s worn.
Which Is More Stable?
It depends on the width and the veneer. Engineered hardwood resists minor gapping better than solid. But narrow solid hardwood is often more stable than wide engineered hardwood.
For example, a 3¼” solid hardwood nailed down will usually be more stable than a 7.5″ engineered plank with a 4 mm veneer. Thick veneers behave a lot like solid wood, and in dry conditions they can dry out, crack, and cup.
So don’t think of engineered floors as immune to humidity changes. Every brand still requires indoor relative humidity to stay between 35% and 55% on average. In Edmonton’s dry winters, a humidifier makes a big difference (more in our hardwood care and maintenance guide).
If you’d rather not monitor humidity closely, a narrow solid hardwood will be more forgiving than a wide, thick-veneer engineered floor.
Durability, Scratches, and Water
The surface of both floors is real hardwood, so their durability day to day is similar. Neither is fully scratch resistant, and both can dent.
A few things help:
- Matte and textured finishes hide scratches and wear better than high gloss. Most engineered hardwood comes matte and wire brushed.
- Harder species like hickory and oak hold up better to pets and busy households.
Neither floor is waterproof. Engineered hardwood has better water resistance against slab moisture thanks to its core, but standing water will damage either one. For bathrooms and laundry rooms, we usually recommend tile or luxury vinyl instead.
Cost and Resale Value
Price per square foot depends on the species, width, grade, and veneer thickness, so engineered isn’t automatically cheaper. A wide engineered plank with a thick veneer can cost as much as solid hardwood.
For resale value, both are real hardwood, which buyers love. The most cost effective choice is the one that suits your space and lasts, so you’re not replacing it early.
Solid Hardwood vs. Engineered: Which Should You Choose?
Solid hardwood flooring is a great choice if you want:
- A custom stain, gloss, width, or grade
- A classic, traditional look
- A floor you can refinish many times
- Extra stability with a narrower plank
- Hardwood on a main or upper floor with a wood subfloor
Engineered hardwood flooring is a great choice if you want:
- Wide, modern planks
- Your floor sooner (1 to 3 weeks)
- Hardwood in a basement or over concrete
- Compatibility with radiant heat (check the product)
- A ready-made look you can see on the sample
See Solid and Engineered Hardwood in Person
The best way to choose is to see both side by side. Visit our showroom at 8327 Roper Road NW, or call us at 780-721-4324. We’ll walk you through the real differences and help you find the right floor for your home.
